Could DREAMS Deliver What STEAM Promises?
I recently returned from China, where I joined colleagues from the National Consortium of STEM Schools for conversations about education and visits with schools. Over the next three weeks, I want to explore some of the ideas I brought home and how they connect with questions I’ve carried through my own work in education.
One of those questions came back into focus through a sign at Shanghai United International School’s Qingpu Campus. It brought together six familiar words in an arrangement that caught my attention. Design, Research, Engineering, Art, Math, and Science. DREAMS.
Educators certainly enjoy an acronym, and I’ve spent enough time around STEM and STEAM to approach another variation with some skepticism. Yet I kept returning to those first two words. Design and Research seemed to offer a way of developing an idea I’ve been working through for years.
During my time leading the Arkansas School for Mathematics, Sciences, and the Arts, I generally preferred “creativity and innovation” as broader organizing principles. Those words gave us room to talk about the capacities we wanted students to develop throughout the school. A student interpreting a musical composition, investigating a scientific question, or developing a computer program could imagine possibilities, exercise judgment, and produce something meaningful. Students whose interests crossed those areas could find connections without having to surrender depth in any of them.
The pairing also helped communicate something that “creativity” alone sometimes leaves unclear. We often associate creativity with artistic expression, even though it also shapes how we formulate questions, adapt methods, and recognize possibilities. Innovation adds the work of developing and applying ideas. Together, those concepts expressed an ambition that felt expansive enough for a school with sciences and arts in its name.
Giving that ambition substance required deliberate choices. Arts students needed expert faculty, appropriate facilities, sustained practice, and opportunities to develop their own artistic identities. Supporting those experiences was part of taking the school’s mission seriously. Meaningful connections among disciplines depend, in part, on having something substantial to bring to the conversation.
That experience helps explain my reservations about STEAM. Adding the arts to STEM can signal an important commitment, but it can also preserve an arrangement in which scientific and technical priorities determine the work. Students complete an engineering challenge and then decorate the product. They investigate a scientific question and illustrate their findings. The arts become visible, while their influence over the purpose and direction of learning remains limited.
This concern has a substantial history among arts educators and researchers. A 2023 review of 27 studies of STEAM learning found that 19 assessed science competencies, while only six assessed any dimension of artistic competence. That finding raises a question about what we consider evidence of success. If we promise integration, we should be able to describe what students are learning artistically with the same care we bring to their scientific development.
The sign in Shanghai offered me a way to continue thinking through that challenge. DREAMS has precedent, including former superintendent Timothy Baird’s explanation of Design and Research as processes connecting the disciplines. What interests me is how those processes might give greater substance to the language I’ve long preferred.
Creativity and innovation establish the aspiration. Design and Research introduce the practices that could help realize it.
Research gives curiosity a method. Students learn to frame questions, choose approaches, examine evidence, and judge what their findings support. That work can take the form of an experiment, a historical investigation, an interview, or close study of an artistic tradition. The standards differ across disciplines, and learning those differences is part of developing expertise.
Design gives intention a form. The word can encompass artistic composition, engineering, and attention to human experience. It also applies to research methodology, programs, and systems. Students make choices about how something should work, what it should communicate, whom it should serve, and how its parts relate to its purpose. They then examine the consequences of those choices and revise.
Together, these practices describe a relationship between understanding and creation. Investigation informs what we make. Making something reveals what we still need to understand. Knowledge grows through that movement, and increasing disciplinary expertise makes both the questions and the possibilities more sophisticated.
This is where my thinking continues to evolve. I can imagine Design and Research providing common practices across a school while supporting deep learning within individual subjects. A musician developing an interpretation and a biologist designing an experiment could both embody that philosophy. Integration would emerge where the work benefits from multiple kinds of expertise.
Consider students proposing a redesign of a school courtyard. They might investigate how people use the space, whose needs it overlooks, and what would make it more welcoming. Questions about temperature, drainage, and plant life would bring scientific knowledge into the work. Dimensions and costs would require mathematics. Materials and structures would draw on engineering. Artistic judgments about form, atmosphere, and meaning would help shape the experience from the beginning.
As proposals developed, those considerations would influence one another. A preferred arrangement might create an accessibility problem. A material might become uncomfortable in the sun. Feedback might challenge students’ assumptions about what their classmates actually want. Research and Design would help them work through those tensions, with each discipline contributing something consequential.
Organizing a school around such practices would require time for teachers to collaborate and students to investigate, practice, and revise. Assessment would need to recognize the quality of their questions and choices alongside their growing subject knowledge. There would also need to be room for artistic expression and open exploration, where the purpose becomes clearer through the work itself.
That is why DREAMS has stayed with me. “Creativity and innovation” still captures much of what I hope education makes possible. Design and Research could help articulate how a school cultivates those capacities, both within its disciplines and through their integration. My interest in the acronym rests on that possibility—and on the opportunity to keep refining my own understanding of what it takes to make the arts and sciences equally consequential in a young person’s education.




Comments